Blog Details

Metal Roofs vs Shingle Roofs

Which Should You Pick in 2024: Shingles or Metal Roofs?

Wondering about your home’s roof? In 2024, lots of folks are asking: Should I go for a metal roof or shingle roof (especially Asphalt type)? Well, it is a tough choice because our homes need good protection and a nice look, right? So, you need to think strategically about metal roofs vs shingle roofs

Let us find a solution to this dilemma by tackling the common questions: Which ones last longer? What’s better for my budget? Can they handle different weather? 

These questions are the key to figuring out what roof is best for you. 

Think of this blog as your go-to guide. We are not just here comparing the metal roofs and shingle roofs – we’re going on an adventure! We’ll look at what makes each roof special, from how tough metal is against bad weather to the classic style of Asphalt shingles. 

[IMPORTANT NOTE: Shingle roofs are of various types. So, we’re comparing metal roofs with asphalt shingles only since Asphalt is the most popular shingle roofing type. Don’t get confused on this!] 

Come along with us as we break down the details, clear up any confusion, and empower you to pick the perfect roof. So, let’s start this Metal roof vs Shingle roof battle. 

Meanings of Each Roofing Type: Metal Roofs vs Shingle Roofs (War 1) 

What are Metal Roofs? 

Metal roofs are roofing systems made primarily of metal materials, including Steel, Aluminum, Copper, and zinc. These roofs are available in large flat sheets and are folded longitudinally in different patterns. The metal roofs are further divided into two: 

Corrugated Metal Roofing

This roofing category of metal roofs has a wavy or rippled pattern and is often used for agricultural and residential applications. 

Flat Seam Metal Roofing 

Also known as low-slope metal roofs, this roofing type has flat, smooth, continuous surfaces. 

What is Asphalt Shingles Roofing? 

Asphalt shingles roofing is a popular roofing type for residential spaces. These shingles are typically made of a fibreglass or organic felt base mat. The base mats are saturated with Asphalt to provide waterproofing and durability benefits. Asphalt shingles are mainly of two types.

3-Tab Shingles 

These shingles are the most common and economical type, featuring a flat appearance with three tabs per shingle. 

Architectural (Dimensional) Shingles

They are thicker and more durable than 3-Tab shingles. Moreover, these shingles have a more layered and textured look. 

Pros & Cons of Each Type: Metal Roofs vs Shingle Roofs (War 2) 

Metal Roof 


  • Highly Durable & Can Last Over 50 Years 
  • Resist Corrosion & Rust 
  • Reflective Coatings Resisting Sun’s Rays 
  • Minimal Maintenance 
  • Environmentally Sustainable Choice 


  • Higher Upfront Cost 
  • Noisy during Rain or Hailstorms 
  • Prone to Denting 
  • Expands & Contracts with Temperature Variation 
  • Colour Fading 

Asphalt Shingle Roofs


  • Cost-Effective 
  • Easy & Quick Installation 
  • Wide Range of Options in Terms of Styles & Colors 
  • Versatile Material
  • Decent Durability & Weather Resistant (Lifespan of 20 to 30 Years) 


  • Relatively Shorter Lifespan Compared to Other Roofing Materials 
  • Contributes to Environmental Waste (Not as Easily Recyclable as Others) 
  • Suspectable to Weathering 
  • Vulnerability to Wind and hail Damage 
  • Periodic Inspections for Damage or Missing Shingles 

Price Comparison: Metal Roofs vs Shingle Roofs (War 3) 

Metal Roofs 

Average Cost

In comparison, metal roofs may cost between $4.5 to $30 per square foot (depending on the type). 

Aluminum Metal Roof: $4 to $10 (Per Square Foot)

Tin Metal Roof: $5.5 to $12 (Per Square Foot) 

Zinc Metal Roof: $6 to $12.5 (Per Square Foot) 

Steel Metal Roof: $6.5 to 416 (Per Square Foot) 

Lead Metal Roof: $10 to $15.5 (Per Square Foot) 

Copper Metal Roof: $15 to $30.5 (Per Square Foot)


Typically, these roofs come with no warranty except for a paint warranty. 

Asphalt Shingles Roofing 

Average Cost

On average, the Asphalt shingles may cost around $3.50 – $5.50 per square foot (depending on the type) 

3-Tab Asphalt Shingle Roof: $4.5 to $8.75 (Per Square Foot) 

Architectural Asphalt Shingle Roof: $4.5 to $12.5 (Per Square Foot) 


The majority of Asphalt shingles come with a warranty. 

In a Nutshell Price Comparison: Metal Roofs vs Shingle Roofs

For 1,000 Sq. Feet of Roof

Metal Roof: $4,000 to $30,000 

Asphalt Shingle Roof: $4,250 to $13,000 

For 2,000 Sq. Feet Roof 

Metal Roof: $8,000 to $60,000  

Asphalt Shingle Roof: $8,000 to $26,000 

For 3,000 Sq. Feet Roof

Metal Roof: $12,000 to $90,000 

Asphalt Shingle Roof: $12,700 to $39,500 

Metal Roofs vs Shingle Roofs: Who Won the Battle in 2024? 

Since we have gotten through all the essential information revolving around Metal Roofs vs Shingle Roofs, it’s time to give a final verdict: which option is better? Considering all the factors, price considerations, and advantages and disadvantages, it is safe to say: 

Asphalt Shingles are a Better Option than Metal Roofs.”

Asphalt Shingles are durable, water-resistant, and require minimal maintenance. Considering the cost factors, we are putting this statement at the top. In a time when inflation is reaching new heights, cost is the topmost concern for every homeowner. 

XR TECH Roofing as Your Reliable Companion 

If you are a Montreal resident who is considering undergoing a roof installation, choose XR TECH Roofing. With 15+ years of experience, XR TECH Roofing is your trusted roofing contractor. The questions on the reliability of our services are irrelevant since XR TECH Roofing is often counted among the best roofing companies in Montreal. Our professional roofers in Montreal ensure a high-quality roofing installation. Whether you choose Asphalt shingles or metal roofs in Montreal, XR TECH Roofing will act as your biggest cheerleader. So, don’t think much; contact us for the best roofing installation services in Montreal. 


John Doe

John Doe

Nostra dapibus varius et semper semper rutrum ad risus felis eros. Cursus libero viverra tempus netus diam vestibulum lorem tincidunt congue porta. Non ligula egestas commodo massa. Lorem non sit vivamus convallis elit mollis.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



    Subscribe Our Newsletter